Here is an interesting fact that i didn’t know until today. There are ten times more people in America who consider themselves ‘Irish’ than the number of people actually living in Ireland itself! Even if you consider the fact that probably more than half those people have less connection to Ireland than they might actually like, it’s still a quite staggering statistic.
Of course, many of those Irish Americans have political opinions about the “struggle back home” and the activities of the terrorist organisation the IRA (Irish republican Army). I’ve heard so called Irish Americans, who haven’t been ‘home’ often if ever, talk about the “Bastard British” and the plight of the “comrades” fighting against the British. I tend to stay silent in such discussion, because as wrong as it might sound, I don’t really know a lot about the Irish problem. All I know is that it’s steeped in history and hatred that goes back years and that I dare say the British did indeed do terrible things to the Irish that helped ensure such entrenched loathing of us.
Having said that, while I sit and listen to those Irish Americans who talk about the “glory of the revolution” and the “battle” I note that these people, like all of us, were appalled at the outrageous acts of terrorism on September 11th 2001. Like everyone, they are keen to see that such a thing never happens again on American soil, yet somehow they feel justified in donating money to funds in order to aid the “battle back home,” a battle that we have, for years and years before 9/11, simply called terrorism.
As a child I grew up in a time when innocent office workers and tourists in London were being killed on a regular basis by bombs planted by the IRA. I sat in a London garden one afternoon and heard the deep boom of the biggest bomb to ever explode in the UK, then watched a thick black plume of smoke snake its way into the air over the city. I’ve been evacuated from parts of London too many times to remember as threats of bombs were called in, some real, some false. I’ve seen the devastation of a shopping mall in Manchester levelled by a huge IRA bomb planted in the back of a truck. I’ve been evacuated from work twice in bomb scares and watched the bomb squad carry out a controlled explosion on one place of work to disable a suspect package. Like anyone having grown up in the 70’s, 80’s and 90’s I watched all this and never once did it ever strike me as glorious or a worthy struggle that might have a peaceful outcome. To me it was just terrorism. Needless hateful violence carried out by murderers and people who are “proud” to fight for what they believe in, but too cowardly to unmask their faces in the process.
Most of the money for this wave of violence, and indeed the violence that still goes on today, comes from the United States. It stands to reason that this would be the case when you consider that there are ten times more ‘Irish Americans’ than Irish people living in Ireland. But it seems that in the shadow of Americas own battle against terrorism, support for the IRA and its political affiliates has begun to fade fast.
Many political and influential voices in the United States are now stepping away from their support, or lack of condemnation, for the the IRA. With Sinn Fein’s leader, Jerry Adams, being shunned by many of the high profile figures who were due to meet him in his trip to America, there would seem to be a change of heart coming from ‘Irish Americans.’
Maybe this change of heart is just because support for the IRA might fly too much in the face of Bush’s war against terrorism too much, and create an unwelcome spotlight and backlash on the person in question. Or maybe the change of heart really is just that, a change of heart. Maybe some Irish Americans are finally figuring out that “the battle back home” isn’t going to be “gloriously won” by setting off bombs, shooting people, and killing innocent men, women and children.
Make no mistake, I’m not saying that I disagree or agree with the political objectives of the likes of Sinn Fein. I’m not invalidating the very real Irish issues at hand. I’m just glad to see that in these violent times it would seem that some of the IRA’s long distant supporters are waking up to the fact that killing more people isn’t getting them any closer to their long term political goals.
—
US snubs ‘send SF vital message’
Irish guns ‘fuel British crime’
IRA issue on US agendas
Sinn Fein warning: Reactions
Sienn Fien
Wrote the following comment on Mar 15, 2005 at 5:25 am
wow! i thoroughly enjoyed the polethera of information, facts and opinions! not to sound unintelligent, but i dont think that i could ever write such a post!! your writing is so elegant and informative!! sorry this is so randome, just wanted to give you some props!
Wrote the following comment on Mar 15, 2005 at 6:04 am
I’ve been following the McCarthey story on the BBC lately, so this post makes an interesting companion to something I was already thinking about. I have long been sympathetic to the political demands of the Irish, but, like you, I fail to see how more violence can solve anything. There’s a similar romanticization of Israel in the US; not to say that the situations in the two countries are the same, but Americans have in general tended to pick certain sides in these debates….the side that the majority feel they identify with, even if, in reality, we claim to be against terrorism, state-sponsored or not.
Nothing like a healthy dose of relativism to help shape our politics, eh?
Wrote the following comment on Mar 15, 2005 at 6:05 am
Oops…*McCartney.
Wrote the following comment on Mar 15, 2005 at 6:22 am
I’ve heard outrage from my Northern Irish Protestant friend at how the IRA hasn’t been given a place in the ‘axis of evil’. North America’s world was thrown for a loop in 2001. Before that bombs going off in other parts of the world didn’t have the same resonance.
Wrote the following comment on Mar 15, 2005 at 9:55 am
This is completely out of left field, but is that picture what you look like now? Are you a blonde? I hear they have more fun :-) (though I can’t imagine how you could possibly have any MORE fun).
Wrote the following comment on Mar 15, 2005 at 6:16 pm
Just heard this track and I had to share it with the few of you who’ll read these comments.Lori McKenna singing ‘Ignorance’Enjoy
Wrote the following comment on Mar 15, 2005 at 5:37 pm
“Your writing is so elegant and informative.” Oh my – I am blushing! Thank you Andrea. The funny thing is at School I hated English. To this day I still don’t really read books that much as it takes me so damn long! I’ve been reading Randy Kennedy’s ‘Subwayland for nearly a frikkin year since I bought the book in New York! If my English teacher could see this site or my ‘Meanwhile’ website she would be amazed I was able to string those sentences together! :-)
Nenaluli, no that’s not what I look like at this very moment. But I go blonde from time to time. Will be doing so again soon probably.It’s interesting that Christine (CrazyWomanWriter) talks about the romanticization of Israel in the US. I once said to an American (Christian) friend, in an off hand manner, that I was angry at watching Israel get away with the things it did, and that I felt we should drop a few thousands bombs on them to see how they like it. I wasn’t serious of course, I was just angry at the time after watching Israeli tanks driving through innocent Palestinians homes to get to supposed terrorist targets. The person I was speaking to was outraged at said to me “Simon don’t say that!!” I enquired as to why they were so annoyed at my comment to which they said “I am an Israelite before I am an American.” – She was born a bought up in rural New Hampshire and has NEVER once travelled beyond the United States borders!
I do find it strange that in the light of the terrorist threat that we live under today the Tony Blair thinks we need to have our civil liberties infringed almost to the same degree that Americans have since 9/11. I am not anti Blair by any means, but on this I think his anti-terror laws are far to broad and unfocused. He wants to erode our freedom as a response to unseen terrorists who want to… erode our freedoms. I was very glad to see the House of Lords overthrow the Governments anti-terror proposals.
It makes me so mad that in today’s society we are so dumbed down that it seems no one either cares or notices when the powers that be slowly take away our social freedoms and rights. The news is often depressing I suppose, and with so much choice of TV entertainment to choose from it’s easier to just watch the Simpsons or something. Plus news these days is often a totally dumbed down mix of sensational stories with equally sensational footage along with the who’s shagging who showbiz bollocks.
Wrote the following comment on Mar 15, 2005 at 11:31 am
well, I don’t know much about the IRA, but I do like green beer!
and blondes do have more fun!!!!!
Wrote the following comment on Mar 15, 2005 at 2:15 pm
Well I know that, personally, growing up in Ireland was a trying experience for me. Constantly having to look over your shoulder. Now the battle back home is . . . ok, ok. So I’ve lived in Alabama my whole life. I don’t get to play that game. My “battle back home” consists of my parents fighting about something stupid. What a sheltered life I’ve lived. I can’t possible understand what some people have been through.
Wrote the following comment on Mar 15, 2005 at 6:31 pm
I’m enjoying the song…especially the little guitar tuning part at the beginning. ;-)
Wrote the following comment on Mar 15, 2005 at 8:33 pm
Hey Simon.. seems like we know some of the same people. Did you use to live in Houston or something? I’d be interested to hear how you know the Magdalene7s, Marzishs, and shaemans of the world.I really like the image at the top of your page.