My friend Becky is an American citizen from the Pacific North Western city of Seattle. She is not currently, and has never been, on the FBI’s most wanted list or indeed in any trouble with the authorities whatsoever. She’s your average honest hard working American girl. However, to the UK Border Agency Becky Lewis is a criminal who must be deported!
Becky has been traveling across the UK over the summer, enjoying a little time out of her ordinary day-to-day life with money she had been saving for just such an adventure. Along the way she’s been couch surfing and volunteering on non-commercial organic farms with an organisation known as WWOOF (World Wide Opportunities on Organic Farms). It’s been an exciting year for her, but thanks to UK immigration her time in Britain came to an abrupt and unpleasant end.
Her ordeal started when we recently returned to the UK from Croatia where we had enjoyed a few days of late summer sun in on the Istrian peninsula. My brother has an apartment in Rovinj so the few days we spent in Croatia was a cheap escape. However, had I known what lay in store for us I would never have gone.
As we stood in the immigration line to re-enter the UK we joked with one another about how surly faced the gate agents looked as they inspected passports of the people who stood before them, treating them with the usual kind of contempt that anyone who has been to an airport can attest to.
I always try to be pleasant with immigration officials, but most of the time they come across as disputatious little people itching to issue punishment for even the most minor of infractions. Their mean disposition probably comes from the lack of job satisfaction that must go along with being the traffic wardens of a countries border, uniformed drones programmed for only the most mundane of duties.
A gate agent motioned for us to approach him. Spitting commands at us in his thick Indian accent the agent sat on his throne behind the safety of a sheet of plexiglass. Perhaps feeling like he was keeping England safe he coldly ignored my attempts at pleasantries in a miserable manner similar to the weather that had welcomed us back to this rainy little island.
He waved me passed with little more than a grunt and I assumed Becky would be grunted back into the UK a few moments later, but no. Apparently her passport had not been stamped by the American immigration department when she re-entered the U.S. after a trip to the UK earlier in the year. This oversight by the American authorities was a “red light” to the uniform wearing unarmed gatekeeper.
Excited at the break in the monotony of his dreary job the gate agent started to ask Becky further questions about her the time she was spending in the UK. Where had she been? How was she affording a six month trip? And what had she been doing? Being an honest soul with nothing to hide Becky answered his questions in the belief that this was simply a minor delay, but unfortunately her honesty was her undoing.
She told the uptight immigration official that as part of her trip to the UK she had done a little volunteer work on some non-commercial organic farms. Perhaps sensing that he might have an opportunity to excursive the little power that his position afforded him the agent asked her to clarify this.
As part of her self funded trip to the UK Becky had set up joined an organisation called ‘WWOOF‘ through which she did unpaid volunteer work on small scale organic farms. For her trouble the ‘farmers’ provided her with a place to stay. To be clear, this DID NOT involve any kind of financial compensation and was something Becky did only to meet interesting people across the country.
Unfortunately for her the immigration officer felt that this constituted “work” and therefore was outside of the bounds of her general visitors visa. She was then detained for further questioning whereupon it was decided that she should be deported, not back to the United States, but to Croatia because this is where she had just come from!
Before she was deported she was taken into custody and jailed in an Immigration Prison called Yarl’s Wood Immigration Removal Centre. The UK border agency are sensitive about Yarl’s Wood being referred to as a ‘prison,’ however with it’s high barbed wire topped walls and lock-up wings it is only not a prison by name. Indeed the facility comes under the authority of the HM Inspectorate of Prisons!
Photographed, fingerprinted, and searched numerous times, Becky was processed into the controversial immigration jail where she would stay for two nights before being taken back to the airport and put on the first flight back to Croatia.
To say that I was furious with the heinously draconian decision to deport her would be a master of understatement. Becky had at worst made a small mistake which could have been dealt with by issuing a verbal or written warning. She was only seeking to enter the UK for two more weeks before leaving to travel to Nepal where she would be teaching children in an orphanage.
Documentation of her onward flights and Nepal trip, and even documentation proving that she would be in the U.S. for Christmas were ignored by chief immigration officer Tony Simon who was to be judge and jury in her case. Rather than using his discretion and treating Becky, a U.S. citizen and therefore a friend of the UK, with the respect and consideration one would expect a friend to be shown, he decided to jail and deport her regardless of the effect.
According to WWOOF UK recent changes to UK immigration laws have confused the issue of ‘wwoofing’ in the UK. Indeed immigration officer Tony Simon apparently told Becky that even couch surfing would be considered a violation of a visitors visa to the UK as it allows a visitor to “extend their stay” in the UK. This statement is at the very least contentious and would seem to reveal something of the legalistic and obnoxiously disagreeable attitude of Stanstead airport’s chief immigration officer Tony Simon.
Angered by the outrageous decision but unable to effect it in any way I felt I should purchase a ticket back to Croatia on the same flight Becky was to be deported on so as to be there for my friend. I collected the luggage she had left at my house and organised another apartment for us to stay at in Croatia. From there we spent a rain soaked week reorganizing her onward plans.
I remain shocked and ashamed at the way Becky was treated by UK immigration. Chief immigration officer Tony Simon undoubtedly wasted tax payers money putting Becky through this ordeal that was, for us both, extremely costly, stressful and time consuming.
In the end, while I doubt we’ll be seeing her return to the UK again any time soon, I’m happy to report that Becky was able to rearrange her onward travel plans and make it to Nepal as planned. I will be writing to the UK authorities to express my anger at the way she was treated, though I have little faith that there will be any redemption in this story.
—
I’m not a crook (Becky’s blog about this)
A Yarl’s Wood detainee speaks out
Britain looks to jail more visitors
UK to build Europe’s largest immigration jail
WWOOF advice on UK immigration
C4 News – Confusion rife in UK border agency removal cases
Inside Yarl’s Wood: Britain’s shame over child detainees
BID – Bail for UK immigration detainees
HM Inspectorate of Prisons report on Yarl’s Wood
→ GET BEFOREiFORGET BY EMAIL, iPHONE, OR PODCAST
Wrote the following comment on Nov 9, 2009 at 7:23 am
Holy cow! And I wanted to go visit England next year. :)
I am so sorry for Becky. I have had my share of obnoxious immigration officers, but this takes the cake. As a “conditional” U.S. permanent resident, I am already a little anxious every time I enter the country… adding a prison (for no reason!) to that would probably send me into a nervous breakdown.
Hugs to you both, and better luck to Becky with her upcoming trips. :)
Wrote the following comment on Nov 9, 2009 at 8:01 am
Bureaucratic madness! I hope you two sort everything out, I am always mystified by the idiocy of some people working in some sectors of public services.
Wrote the following comment on Nov 9, 2009 at 12:00 pm
I cannot believe my eyes this morning Simon ~ I had been wonder what was up. I had strong feeling something was wrong. But I also have been innocently caught up in something. I haven’t broken any laws and don’t want to take away any attention from what has been happening to Becky and you. But there is something SERIOUSLY wrong in this country at the moment. Your opening word YARL was a link to my September/October/November but it is much wider and deeper than that link. This country’s attitude on Becky’s situation beggars belief but unfortunately the INNOCENT are being given a ridiculously hard time while the actual CRIMINALS are scamming their way into this country. I know I might sound as if I am talking in riddles but until tomorrow I have to keep the rest of my ongoing experience to myself. All I would say is like you, with Croatia, I wish for the first time that I had never gone to Africa to live. I am so glad to be settled back in the Uk but flip me what is wrong with the Authorities in our country Simon? I am really glad for Becky that she had your support in this. Crumbs, I hope Becky is Ok now. You are a true friend to her Simon.
Wrote the following comment on Nov 9, 2009 at 12:50 pm
Oh my word! That seems like an awfully harsh way to deal with someone from a country that has a supposed “special relationship” with us! I’m sorry your friend was treated so badly. At least it didn’t screw up her trip to Nepal.
Wrote the following comment on Nov 9, 2009 at 3:39 pm
You have to wonder at the intelligence of some people. Sadly I think we’re living in a country that is drowning under a tidal wave of bureaucratic nonsense. It seems that fewer and fewer people are able to use their brains and apply some common sense to all kinds of situations. I find that people who wear uniforms to be particularly incapable of using any common sense so it really doesn’t surprise me that this kind of thing happens. What a terrible shame though that your friend had to be put through all of this. With ‘friends’ like us who needs enemies!
Wrote the following comment on Nov 9, 2009 at 8:12 pm
Appalling way to treat anyone, but I’m very surprised they treated an American like that. I agree with Max, Britain is fast becoming an overbearing police state. That’s why I like it here in rural Ireland. Tell your friend Becky she can still come see us!
Wrote the following comment on Nov 10, 2009 at 2:39 pm
What a traumatic thing for your poor friend, and well done to you for flying back to Croatia with her to help her out! I must say that while this is clearly a serious post I did have to laugh at the captions you put on the pictures, my favourite being “Miserable bureaucratic border bot.” I often feel that way when I look at those immigration people whenever I return to the UK from a holiday.
Wrote the following comment on Nov 11, 2009 at 5:54 am
I always wonder why the US immigration guards have guns. I’ve yet to see them gun down someone like your friend, but perhaps that’s how we get around the costs involved with jailing our Becky’s; we just gun them down right there in the line.
“Wait a second, you worked!!” BANG BANG BANG… BANG!!!
“Next.”
Glad you’re friend avoided the firing squad and was able to get to Nepal with your help dude!
Wrote the following comment on Nov 11, 2009 at 3:20 pm
What a complete nightmare! I can’t even begin to imagine how distressing that was for her, and for you to I suspect. What a horrible horrible horrible thing to happen.
Wrote the following comment on Nov 12, 2009 at 2:01 pm
I’m sorry about what happened to your friend. It’s truly an awful experience.
You might be interested in learning that Sir Al Aynsley-Green, the children’s commissioner for England (politician), wrote a report calling for the practice of jailing of children in this way to be stopped. He said that putting children, and indeed any innocent person, in a facility like Yarl’s Wood UK immigration detention centre (now officially called a “removal centre”), was “inhumane” and broke “common standards of decency.”
His report was backed by the childrens charity, Barnardo’s, the chief executive of which is Martin Narey, the former head of the Prison Service!
You can read more about this on the BBC website. Detention of children ‘must stop’ and Mark Easton’s BBC blog, Children in detention at Yarl’s Wood.
The Government has previously ignored a call by the childrens charity ‘Save the Children’ to end the jailing of innocent children which the charity say is harmful to children.
The fact that your friend was jailed and deported, despite being able to prove her ‘innocence’ highlights again that the whole immigration system is a mess.
Simon, I hope it’s okay with you if I ask anyone who reads this blog and feels that jailing innocent children is wrong to sign a petition set up on the Prime Ministers website. There are currently 2117 names on the petition and if you are a UK citizen you can sign the petition online today.
Wrote the following comment on Nov 12, 2009 at 5:10 pm
Amy, thanks for that comment. I’ve signed that petition though curiously the number didn’t change even though my name got added to the list.
As you might imagine I have read quite a bit about our immigration system now and it would appear to be in complete disarray and utterly entangled in needly bureaucracy.
It’s truly alarming to read about the treatment of children in our immigration system and so I too would urge anyone reading this to consider signing the petition against the imprisonment of innocent children.
Wrote the following comment on Nov 12, 2009 at 11:07 pm
Reading that blog I see that you do hyperbole especially well. A career in writing for a tourist board awaits you, somewhere
Wrote the following comment on Nov 13, 2009 at 3:30 pm
I personally didn’t see any children while I was there, other than the daughter of a Croatian lady that had been on the flight from Rovinj and to Zadar, and I don’t know how she was treated.
This whole situation is appalling and I just can’t get over the fact that it exists. I’m going to sign the petition right now, thanks for bringing it to my attention.
p.s. I am now in Nepal and doing great, experiencing this and forgetting about how I left England.
Wrote the following comment on Nov 13, 2009 at 4:18 pm
Great to hear you’re doing well Becky! Nepal, that sounds so exciting. I’m about to leave work here in Edinburgh and venture into the cold dark rain. Anywhere sounds better than that right now! Good luck on your travels!
PS. I have now also signed that petition.
Wrote the following comment on Nov 13, 2009 at 10:29 pm
Interesting blog. Fitting title, by the way.
I’m sorry to hear about Becky’s ordeal. I hope it doesn’t put her off future visits to the UK. I know what it’s like to be banged-up (in my wild young days – long since mellowed, mind you), and even for a few days, it can be grim staring at four walls and a barred window.
Granted, it’s common for low-level drones to act by the book, but I’d have thought a Chief Immigration Officer would have sensed the situation and used his discretion in this case. The problem with bureaucracy is that the rulebook can’t cover every eventuality. And not every official has the ability to read a situation and the courage to improvise a solution. To do so takes them out of their comfort zone, and be more than their job’s worth. All they can do then is force the situation to ‘fit’ a fixed set of parameters, unfortunately resulting in what happened to Becky.
However, I wouldn’t be surprised if it’s policy to send more people to Yarl’s Wood High-security Prison (sorry, Immigration Removal Centre) to justify the expense of building it. Cynical, I know, but there isn’t much I’d put past our government these days.
A lively and engaging piece of writing though; I especially liked the image of the immigration officer sitting on his throne behind the plexi-glass – very well-observed.
But I wonder what’s worse: petty, by-the-book bureaucrats who aren’t capable of independent thought, or ‘writers’ who scoff at other people’s efforts? (Hyperbole? What an exaggeration ;-))
All the best and keep up the good work. I’ll follow future blogs with interest.
Cheers.
Wrote the following comment on Nov 14, 2009 at 10:57 pm
I had to smile when I read your blog, Simon. You slagged off the immigration officer who, after all, was merely doing his job and is not here to answer back. That’s where the hyperbole was at its most pronounced. He didn’t make the rules and didn’t build Yarl’s Wood. On the other hand, the WWOOF/UK website makes it clear here that there are issues around WWOOFing and immigration concerning the UK. (I found that page easily enough.) You may feel your friend was unfairly treated but perhaps you should have criticised her too for not having done a bit of basic research. If you’re so keen on the ‘blame game’, you ought to have included her as well.
Spitting commands at us in his thick Indian accent
What did the officer’s accent have to do with it? Would you have mentioned the accent if it had been Scouse, Geordie, Welsh, Manunian or from any other region of the UK? I somehow think not.
Wrote the following comment on Nov 15, 2009 at 3:38 pm
What a terrible experience. I have undergone something very similar myself.
It’s terrible that the UK has come to this, but had Becky simply claimed asylum she would have been waved through, given housing, income, and medical care.
Wrote the following comment on Nov 15, 2009 at 5:39 pm
Wow, Ive heard this story so many times. The UK customs agency has got to be one of the worst beaurocratic messes ive ever seen. I have Wwoofed and Couchsurfed in the UK before and personally didnt run into any trouble. possibly because I entered the UK by crossing from Ireland to Northern Ireland and never went through British customs (something they didnt find amusing upon my exiting the country after four undocumented months). a close friend of mine (american citizen) was denied entry into england from holland for being at risk of “not staying in one place” and “not having enough friends”. this was despite that she already had proof of onward travel, funds, a friend waiting to pick her up at the ferry port and the only reason she wanted to come to the UK was to visit a specific church on easter. its really a shame that the UK finds it so neccesary to treat well meaning individuals as criminals. I plan on returning to Great Britain at some point but hell, I think i’ll do what I did last time, skip customs and just take a bus to belfast and a ferry to scotland.
Wrote the following comment on Nov 15, 2009 at 7:26 pm
@ S2 – That was a smooth move getting into the UK under the radar as it were.
@ Tony B – It seems that you’ve rather missed the point here Tony. The Chief Immigration Officer (Tony Simon, not the Indian gate agent) has the power to exercise his discretion in ALL cases put before him. He has this discretion in the same way that a police officer has discretion. So while ‘rules are rules’ it remains an absurdity that Becky, who proved she was leaving the UK in two weeks, was jailed and deported. The cost to the taxpayer of doing this to someone who was clearly going to be leaving shortly, was an entirely unnecessary expense not to mention the fact that it was a shockingly draconian way of dealing with this minor infraction of the rules.
Thanks for pointing out that page to the WWOOF website. I had actually linked to it from the blog post. Indeed that page states that “the [UK immigration] situation has become confused” so I’m sure you join me in hoping that confusion will be clarified soon. So while I do accept that your suggestion that Becky is somewhat to blame for possibly traveling on the wrong kind of visa, this wasn’t really the point of my post.
Regarding what I wrote about the gate agents “thick Indian accent” you’re absolutely right, I wouldn’t have mentioned it if he had a British accent. I just found it ironic is all.
Wrote the following comment on Nov 16, 2009 at 2:44 am
As it happens I heard another very similar story to Becky’s this afternoon from my room mate. His sister in law was recently refused entry to the UK for reasons that seem a little murky to me – something about her previous foreign travel to Asian countries. She has traveled extensively for a medical organization (not sure which one). The dumb thing is the UK allowed her husband entry but refused her. Their vacation to England ruined they both returned to New York shocked, angry and disappointed.
Wrote the following comment on Nov 16, 2009 at 9:27 am
Tony, it seems that you’ve rather missed the point here
No, on the contrary, I think you’ve missed the point. In your blog you wrote a lot that was critical about the Indian gate officer. That officer was in no way to blame for your friend’s situation. You may feel that the UK immigration service’s position is unjust. Fine. I’m sure that many here would agree with you. As it happens, I do too. But that’s no reason to absolve your friend of all responsibility in your blog, nor is it any reason for you to make carping personal criticisms about the gate officer. Aiming at a soft target is no proof of good marksmanship.
Had your friend Becky been a recently naturalised British subject and had just got a job as an immigration gate officer, I’m sure you would have joined me in condemning any poster who referred to her accent in a derogatory way. Whether you meant it or not, your reference to the gate officer’s accent could be interpreted as being racist.
Wrote the following comment on Nov 16, 2009 at 6:47 pm
Tony, I’d rather not get into a pointless back-and-forth with you so allow me to once again state this is terms that will at last be absolutely clear for you and help you understand the point of my the blog post.
What happened to Becky was needlessly draconian – THAT was the point of what I wrote. The chief immigration officer, Tony Simon, could have exercised his discretion and dealt with the very minor infraction in any number of ways that would have been less disruptive, traumatic, not to mention costly to the British tax payer.
Your previous suggestion that I am playing some kind of “blame game” is utterly preposterous! The confusion surrounding WWOOFing in the UK this summer has been problematic and will hopefully be resolved soon. Yes, perhaps Becky should have obtained a full work visa, easier still, maybe Becky should never have mentioned WWOOFing to the gate agent, or the chief immigration officer.
The fact remains that her deportation was an extremely draconian and unnecessary way to deal with such a minor infraction ESPECIALLY given the fact that Becky proved that she would be leaving the UK in just 2 weeks and had no plans to WWOOF or otherwise work in that time period. She was well budgeted and the immigration service had numerous ways they could have dealt with her mistake other than that which they ultimately chose. Jailing and deporting her created a great deal of work for the immigration service, and the various other agencies involved. It will also create more needless work should Becky decide to return to the UK.
I hope this lengthy reiteration has helped you now understand the point of the post Tony. I’m sure you join me in hoping that the apparent confusion that exists surrounding WWOOFing and UK visas is soon resolved so that there are no further incidents like Becky’s.
Wrote the following comment on Nov 16, 2009 at 8:34 pm
Wow, …I wondered why Simon’s phone still had an international dial tone when I last called. That’s an ordeal and a half you both went through. Glad you are both ok, I shook my head in shock when I read this. You hear about this kind of thing happening (you know, the “average Jo” in society that somehow end-up directly or indirectly being used as political pawns) and never thought it would happen to someone I know. Hope Becky made it to Nepal safely and look forward to those travel tales, see you soon Xx
Wrote the following comment on Nov 17, 2009 at 12:41 am
Did you actually read my post #21? If you did, were there any parts of it that you didn’t understand?
Wrote the following comment on Nov 17, 2009 at 1:22 am
Yes Tony, I did read and completely understand all parts of your response. Thanks for taking the time to write it.
Wrote the following comment on Nov 17, 2009 at 4:53 am
LOL, I saw that racist accusation from Tony B coming a mile off. Poor guy is clearly looking for a fight and you’re just not playing Simon. :-)
Wrote the following comment on Nov 17, 2009 at 7:30 am
At a time when tourism numbers are falling, it’s not the smartest move deporting legitimate tourists.
Wrote the following comment on Nov 17, 2009 at 8:56 am
I’m afraid that rules are rules, and the decision to deport Becky was one hundred per cent correct. Yes, common sense and humanity say that she should have been treated differently, but that is not how the world works. And equally absurd decisions are made every day by US immigration authorities.
Wrote the following comment on Nov 17, 2009 at 12:02 pm
@ David – Of course “rules are rules” but that’s absolutely not “how the world works.” Thankfully this country is full of people who are willing and able to use their discretion to apply a little common sense to situations in order to prevent this country from grinding to a rule crippled halt.
Imagine the hellish state of affairs if their was suddenly absolutely zero chance of discretion with rules. Suddenly police everywhere would find themselves unable to deal with the amount of ‘crime’ across the country as they stopped to issue penalty notices to every single motorist who was one even mile an hour over the speed limit. They would also have to stop and make sure that every person they saw drinking from a bottle on the street was not doing so from a glass vessel, and if they were then that person would have to be arrested, detained and processed, then dealt with by the courts at a later date.
I don’t know about you David, but I am thankful that’s not how the world works.
Wrote the following comment on Nov 17, 2009 at 2:29 pm
Wait a second, the police would arrest you from drinking from a glass bottle?
Wrote the following comment on Dec 1, 2009 at 4:38 pm
It’s depressing that this country is become a place filled with uniformed drones who are unable to use their own common sense.
I got a parking ticket the other day for obstucing a driveway – MY damn driveway! The idiot drone, who was hardly able to speak English, told me that it didn’t matter that I was parked across my own driveway because “rules is rules mate.”
Rules IS rules? There is nothing down for us when the drones don’t even have a handle on our language!
Wrote the following comment on Nov 17, 2009 at 2:43 pm
Yes Hannah. In a “rules are rules” world the act of drinking in public from a glass bottle would be an offense according to a long forgotten English law regarding drinking from “an open glass vessel” in public.
These days the law has been further clarified, mostly at local levels by individual local authorities who use ASBO’s (Anti Social Behaviour Orders) regulate the practice under new provisions making it an offense to “Possess or drink from any open vessel containing intoxicating liquor in any public place.”
Wrote the following comment on Nov 17, 2009 at 6:01 pm
Let’s not forget also that it is illegal to be drunk in a public place anywhere in the UK. In David’s strict “rules are rules” world the government would have to build enormous new mega-prisons to manage the sheer number of weekend revelers who find themselves drunk in public. And while that sounds ridiculous it’s worth noting that, as you have already pointed out Simon, the government do indeed plan on building a new mega-prison for immigration detainees.
Wrote the following comment on Nov 21, 2009 at 10:34 pm
Wow- what a horrible thing to have happen.
When I went to the USA I think the immigration guy was on drugs. He almost forgot to do the finger print/photo thing, stamped my passport 3 times but didn’t fill in any of the stamps properly it turns out. According to one of the stamps he gave me entrance for a year instead of 3 months! I was very lucky upon leaving that the exit guy fixed it all up.
Glad you are doing well Becky.
Wrote the following comment on Nov 25, 2009 at 4:13 pm
Bad news. To be honest, I’m trying to leave the UK. I find it’s changed beyond the threshold of my liking the place – and I left my own country because I liked it so much here at first…
If the guy was Indian, Simon, it’s worth remembering how you deal with immigration officers in India: say as little as possible and yes sir no sir, don’t know sir. They’re the masters of petty officialdom. But too late now. Hope Becky enjoys Nepal, she won’t have that kind of problem there! Really easy going.
Wrote the following comment on Dec 2, 2009 at 8:01 am
wow.. that’s horrible.
Wrote the following comment on Dec 4, 2009 at 5:17 pm
Hi Simon:
I am sorry about what happened to Becky. But full marks to you for publicizing this very effectively. You are a great evangelizer and my respect for you is very high especially the way you handled 1and1.com.
Regards
Wrote the following comment on Dec 4, 2009 at 5:24 pm
Thanks Norman. And thanks for the respect about my 1and1 complaint site. That web page gets a great deal of traffic, but lets fact it, 1and1 internet are among the worst web hosts in the world! :-)